Controversy

Challenging the Zonal Acarya System, Part 15
BY: SUN EDITORS - 27.5 2023 Page twenty-seven THE SPIRITUAL MASTERS ARE EQUAL Recently the issue of "representative of Krsna," was discussed with one guru. When it was proposed to him that the temple presidents of the devotees in our centers were also Krsna's...Read more...
Challenging the Zonal Acarya System, Part 14
BY: SUN EDITORS - 25.5 2023 Page twenty-six We should stop and soberly consider, before allowing this issue to degenerate to lower levels of disagreement. These days, epitaphs like "envious snake" are being flung around with abandon. This is not at all good. We are presenting...Read more...
Challenging the Zonal Acarya System, Part 11
BY: SUN EDITORS - 19.5 2023 Page twenty-one LIMITATIONS OF THE MADHYAMA GURU The qualifications of the uttama adhikari are mentioned in the Nectar of Devotion. The new gurus seem to concede that they are not on this platform of realization. "Yes, the guru has to prove himself by...Read more...
Challenging the Zonal Acarya System, Part 10
BY: SUN EDITORS - 18.5 2023 Page twenty MOOD OF PRABHUPADA DURING APPOINTMENTS Before the disappearance of His Divine Grace Srila Prabhupada, he organized and planned the entire future of the Krsna Consciousness movement by delegating the responsibility of management to the GBC, and...Read more...
Challenging the Zonal Acarya System, Part 9
BY: SUN EDITORS - 16.5 2023 Page eighteen THE AUTHORITY OF SRIDHAR SWAMI One sannyasi recently quipped in Vrindavan, "They (the devotees of the Gaudiya Math) are all envious of our movement. We don't need to listen to Sridhar Swami. We took some advice from him, and now we don...Read more...
Challenging the Zonal Acarya System, Part 8
BY: SUN EDITORS - 12.5 2023 Page sixteen THE EXTENT OF GBC AUTHORITY The post of GBC is designed to manage only. Prabhupada has specifically said that preaching is mutually exclusive from it. The post is a service, it is not a spiritual designation. This also applies to the new guru...Read more...
Challenging the Zonal Acarya System, Part 7
BY: SUN EDITORS - 10.5 2023 page fifteen ARE THE SASTRAS LOSING GROUND? Is sastric authority losing ground in ISKCON? Has the authority of ISKCON now become limited to a particular group of devotees as the all-in-all, with no sastric check and balance system? Even has it come to the...Read more...
Challenging the Zonal Acarya System, Part 6
BY: SUN EDITORS - 10.5 2023 Page twelve In his declaration of will, dated June, 1977, His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada stated that, "The Governing Body Commission (GBC) will be the ultimate managing authority of the entire International Society for Krishna...Read more...
Constitutional Issues: Differing Positions on Guru-tattva
BY: ROCANA DASA - 10.5 2023 We are continuing to receive many interesting emails and submissions on issues related to guru-tattva and the Constitution for ISKCON As It Is. We appreciate hearing from all the devotees on these topics. One devotee offered this characterization of...Read more...
Constitutional Issues: Disciplic Succession
BY: ROCANA DASA - 9.5 2023 Originally published in May 2015, following release of the draft Constitution. I would like to address the issues recently brought up by two Sun readers, Haridasa dasa and Krishna dasa regarding an essential principle within our philosophy...Read more...
Challenging the Zonal Acarya System, Part 4
BY: SUN EDITORS - 8.5 2023 Page nine HOW OTHER SAMPRADAYAS KEEP ACARYA IN THE CENTER The new gurus maintain vehemently that they are keeping Srila Prabhupada in the center. But we have presented some reasons for our not being able to fully accept this assertion. It would be to our...Read more...
Challenging the Zonal Acarya System, Part 3
BY: SUN EDITORS - 8.5 2023 Page seven WHY THE CONTROVERSY THEN? We have just previously quoted certain statements made by either initiating gurus or other leaders of the movement, the gist of them being that everything in regard to this new guru process is being very enthusiastically...Read more...
Challenging the Zonal Acarya System, Part 2
BY: SUN EDITORS - 5.3 2023 Before we continue in presenting part two of this paper, we would like to offer a few comments. First, this manuscript is formatted in many sections with very long passages, which can be quite difficult to read on a computer screen. We have taken the liberty of...Read more...
Constitutional Issues: 'Rubber-stamp' Approvals, Part 3
BY: ROCANA DASA - 5.5 2023 In our continued discussions on the constitutional issue of diksa guru rubber-stamping, a reader offered the following comment and question: "In essence, the [ISKCON As It Is] institution does not require any additional standards for being a guru. So it is...Read more...
Challenging the Zonal Acarya System
BY: SUN EDITORS - 4.5 2023 Today we begin what will be a lengthy serial presentation of a paper written by a collective of Srila Prabhupada disciples, released on February 17, 1979 in Vrindavan. The paper was presented to the new 'Zonal Acaryas' in an effort to share concerns about...Read more...
Srila Prabhupada was poisoned with Cadmium
By editor - 2.3 2023 Best of all the truth videos so far! Spiritual revolution happening as the news & proof that Srila Prabhupada was poisoned with Cadmium is making waves across the Vaishnavas world. The GBC are toast, we have to take them down & we have to stop them from...Read more...
ISKCON Mythology and the Actual Facts
“None Dare Call it a(n) Isk-conspiracy, ISKCON Mythology and the Actual Facts” Challenging the SAAS (Self-Appointed Acarya Sabha) and the LGEP (Living Guru Experimental Project) By Yasoda nandana dasa - 2.3 2023 nama oṁ viṣṇu-pādāya kṛṣṇa-preṣṭhāya bhū-tale śrīmate...Read more...
Hijab Controversy – A Monk’s Perspective
By Vraja Bihari Das - 10.2 2023 “That knowledge by which one undivided spiritual nature is seen in all living entities, though they are divided into innumerable forms, you should understand to be in the mode of goodness.” (Bhagavad Gita- 18.20) “You are a monk, and...Read more...
Religion and Hinduism
By Dayananda Das - 26.12 2022 The words “religion” and “Hindu” are problematic. Both are confusing, inaccurate, and not useful words. Religion Depending on the context, the use of the word religion can be ill-defined and even offensive—for example, when...Read more...
Conspiracy theories
The Monk’s Podcast with Madhavananda Prabhu - 23.9 2022   Succinctly summarised by Chaitanya Charan Prabhu from 1.30.59: So, we discussed today broadly on the topic of going beyond conspiracy theories. We may blame people individually when we face problems, either our own...Read more...
The Criminal Code of FISKCON
By editor - 4.5 2022 Urukrama Dasa – USA: We have been observing FISKCON`s unhealthy dynamics for a while now and it struck us with wonder; the sheer amount of devious activities that individuals can get away with, provided that they are willing to follow well rehearsed and...Read more...
“Book Changes Controversy” Coming to a Close
By Bhaktivedanta Book Trust  - 15.4 2022 On October 17, 2019, the BBT and GBC cooperatively appointed an Editorial Review Panel (ERP) to address devotees’ concerns about making changes to Srila Prabhupada’s books after his physical departure. Formed with the mandate to...Read more...
The Mind-Control Controversy: Brainwashing
By editor - 29.12 2021 Back To Godhead July 1983 A theologian and a historian of religion examine “the new bigotry.” In a misguided attempt to make sense of the exit of thousands of young adults from mainstream society into new and alternative religious movements, “...Read more...
GBC Amends and Affirms Law Allowing Vaisnavis To Initiate
By editor - 23.12 2021 December 22, 2021—The Governing Body Commission (GBC) of ISKCON today passed a resolution amending a 2019 law affirming that qualified Vaisnavis, or women devotees, may under certain conditions, initiate disciples (give diksa) within the International Society for...Read more...
Round Earth in a Flat Cosmology
By editor - 15.12 2021 In an earlier post (which now seems ages ago), I had described the meaning of “flat earth”. The simple idea was that the flatness was an artifact of the model rather than our observation. This point has oft been repeated in my book...Read more...
Syndicate content